Simply Baseball Notebook, etc.

Banished: Heinie Zimmerman

Career Paths
Marcus' Memoirs


Chicago Cubs 1907-16
New York Giants 1916-19

Depending on who you ask, Heinie Zimmerman was the first National Leaguer to win the Triple Crown in the 20th Century and the only third baseman to accomplish the feat. Since RBI (runs batted in) wasn't an official statistic until 1920 and his total in 1912 was disputed, many won't include Zimmerman on the elite list of Triple Crown winners. Since his entire career was surrounded by controversy, it is only fitting that Zimmerman's "Triple Crown" is still subject to debate.

Henry Zimmerman was born on February 9, 1887 in New York City. He debuted with the Chicago Cubs in 1907, and acted as the team's utility man until 1911 when he took over as the everyday third baseman. After batting .307 in 143 games that season, Zimmerman was primed for the season that would define his career.

The 25-year-old finished the 1912 season with a .372 average, 14 home runs and 103 RBI, all of which led the NL. However after a careful recount, Zimmerman's RBI total dropped to 99, which dropped him out of the league lead. In any case, Zimmerman had a career year and finished 6th in the NL MVP voting. (Today most sources list his RBI total in 1912 as 99, but some still tout him as a Triple Crown winner).

Always known as the rowdy type, Zimmerman was involved in a post game fight with umpire Bill Finneran in 1912 and was ejected three times in five games in June of 1913. The string of ejections prompted a fan to send him half of a $100 bill, which included a letter that promised the other half if Zimmerman could go two weeks without getting another ejection.

After hitting .313, .296 and .265 from 1913-15, the veteran was dealt to his hometown, New York Giants in August of 1916. In 1917, the Giants won the NL pennant and faced the Chicago White Sox in the World Series. With his team trailing the Series three games to two, Zimmerman made a costly throwing error in the 4th inning of Game 6 and allowed Eddie Collins to score on a botched rundown. The Sox won the game and the Series, and Zimmerman was left as the goat.

In February of 1919, the Giants acquired 1B Hal Chase from the Cincinnati Reds. Chase, who had been accused of fixing games several times during his career, quickly struck up a friendship with Zimmerman. In September of that season, with the Giants in a heated pennant race, manager John McGraw suspended the pair indefinitely without explanation. Neither one ever played another inning of major league baseball.

At the Black Sox trial in September of 1920, McGraw testified that he had sent Chase and Zimmerman home during the 1919 season because he had strong evidence that the duo was fixing games and had tried to enlist teammates Fred Toney, Rube Benton, and Benny Kauff in their scam. After that testimony both Zimmerman and Chase were permanently banned from baseball by Commissioner Kenesaw Mountain Landis.

In Zimmerman's 13 year career, he posted a .295 average with 1,566 hits, 58 HR, 796 RBI and 175 stolen bases. The former ballplayer remained in his native New York until his death on March 14, 1969. It is unclear if he ever applied for reinstatement.

-David Zingler, March 2004


Zimmerman @

Simply Baseball Notebook

DISCLAIMER: All pictures are assumed to be in the public domain. No violation of copyright is intended here. If one of the photos above is not in the public domain, please notify us and it will be removed.