Simply Baseball Notebook's Forgotten In Time

Jack Taylor

Hilton Smith
Larry Doby
Seattle Pilots
1994 Expos
Ray Chapman
Flashes in the Pan
Steve Blass
St. Louis Browns
Wally Pipp
Rocky Colavito
Dom DiMaggio
Ellis Valentine
Bill Buckner
Jim Bottomley
The Federal League
Stuart 'Slim' Jones
Billy Hamilton
Ed Delahanty
Eddie Waitkus
George Davis
Riggs Stephenson
1920 White Sox
Luke Easter
Herb Washington
Eddie Robinson
Bobby Mathews
Jimmy Ryan
A.G. Spalding
"Dummy" Hoy
Albert Belle
Jack Quinn
Ken Williams
Al Oliver
Jack Taylor
Fred Lindstrom
Jim Thorpe


Chicago Cubs 1898-1903, 06-07
St. Louis Cardinals 1904-06

When pondering the most unbreakable record in baseball history, the first things that may come to mind are Cy Young’s 511 career victories, Joe DiMaggio’s 56 game hitting streak, and Rickey Henderson’s 1,406 career stolen bases.  Seldom, if ever, does anyone point out Jack Taylor’s string of 187 consecutive complete games, when in fact, there is no chance it will ever be approached.


John W. Taylor was born on January 14, 1874 in New Straitsville, OH.  He began his major league career as a 24-year-old in 1898 with the National League’s Chicago Cubs and was an immediate success, going 5-0 with a 2.20 ERA.


Although he compiled a losing record over the next two seasons (a combined 28-38), Taylor solidified his reputation as an innings eater, completing 64 of his 65 starts.  On June 20, 1901, he pitched a complete game, which began an impressive streak that lasted for over five years.  Taylor would go just 13-19 that season, but better times were still to come.


In 1902, Taylor had the best season of his career, posting a 23-11 record and leading the NL with a microscopic 1.33 ERA.  He followed that up with another 20 win season in 1903 (21-14), but found himself in the midst of controversy following the season.


In October 1903, the Cubs and White Sox arranged for an exhibition which would become known as the “City Series.”  Taylor, the Cubs ace, started and won the first game 11-0, but lost his next three starts which left the series tied at seven games apiece. 


White Sox owner Charles Comiskey hoped to continue the series, but Cubs owner Jim Hart would not.  Hart believed that Taylor had thrown his last three starts and refused to complete the exhibition series.  Two months later, Taylor was dealt with Larry McLean to the St. Louis Cardinals for Mike O’Neill and future Hall of Famer Mordecai “Three Finger” Brown.


Taylor pitched well for the Cardinals in 1904, going 20-19 with a 2.22 ERA and a major league record 39 complete games, but the “City Series” controversy surfaced again during his first visit to Chicago.  In response to heckling fans, Taylor reportedly blurted out “Why should I have won?  I got $100 from Hart for winning, and $500 for losing.”


After word of that statement reached Hart, he went public with his accusation for the first time.  The games’ ruling body, the National Commission, failed to act, however, because the games in question were exhibitions, not league sanction contests.  The Commission also feared the negative publicity an inquiry would draw, and hoped the story would simply go away. It wouldn’t.


In July 1904, a rumor began to spread that Taylor tanked a game against the Pittsburgh Pirates.  National League president Garry Herrmann even went so far as to say that Taylor was “not an honest player”.  When Taylor was questioned by the Commission about his behavior during the game in question, he said that he had been out drinking the night before the game and attributed his poor pitching to a hangover.  He was fined $300 for bad conduct.


Taylor remained in St. Louis for the 1905 season, but went just 15-21. Following the season, he was again accused of throwing games in a “City Series”, this time in the Cardinals – Browns affair.  The Cardinals however, did not act on the accusation and Taylor remained with the team until July in 1906, when he was dealt back to the Cubs.  By this time, Jim Hart had sold his stake in the team.


Despite all of the controversy, Taylor kept starting and finishing games.  On August 9, 1906, Taylor defeated the Brooklyn Dodgers 5-3.  It was his 187th consecutive complete game.  Four days later those same Dodgers would knock him out of the game in the third inning, ending one of sport's most impressive streaks.  During the course of the streak, he went the distance during an 18 inning and 19 inning game and pitched both ends of a doubleheader.


Taylor finished the 1906 season with a 20-12 record (12-3 with the Cubs) and 1.99 ERA.  He returned to the Cubs in 1907 for one final big league season, fashioning a 7-5 mark and 3.29 ERA before being released.  He would continue to pitch in the minor leagues for several more years before retiring.


In his big league career, Taylor went 152-139 with a 2.66 ERA. He completed 278 of his 286 starts.  Jack Taylor returned to his native Ohio following his playing days, and on March 4, 1938, he died at the age of 63.


-David Zingler, October 2004


Taylor @

Simply Baseball Notebook

DISCLAIMER: All pictures are assumed to be in the public domain. No violation of copyright is intended here. If one of the photos above is not in the public domain, please notify us and it will be removed.