Simply Baseball Notebook's Legends

Dan Brouthers

Josh Gibson
Hack Wilson
Roger Maris
Cool Papa Bell
'Home Run' Baker
Satchel Paige
Cy Young
Eddie Mathews
Henry Aaron
Mickey Mantle
Ted Williams
Frank Robinson
Willie Mays
Lou Gehrig
Babe Ruth
Dan Brouthers
Joe Jackson
Walter Johnson
Honus Wagner
Ty Cobb
Wee Willie Keeler
John M. Ward
Grover C. Alexander
'Old Hoss' Radbourn
Warren Spahn
Hank Greenberg
Tris Speaker
Napoleon Lajoie
Jimmie Foxx
Christy Mathewson
Mel Ott
Harry Heilmann
Stan Musial
George Sisler
Roy Campanella
Rogers Hornsby


Troy Trojans 1879-80; Buffalo Bisons 1881-85; Detroit Wolverines 1886-88; Boston Beaneaters 1889; Boston Reds 1890-91; Brooklyn Grooms 1892-93; Baltimore Orioles 1894-95; Louisville Colonels 1895; Philadelphia Phillies 1896; New York Giants 1904

The late 19th Century was a make or break time for professional baseball.  Many teams relocated or disappeared completely, but the seeds of the modern game were sown.  Players like Cap Anson, Hugh Duffy, and Cy Young ushered the game into the 20th Century.  In a game that was characterized by a slap hitting, "hit 'em were they aint" philosophy, "Big" Dan Brouthers provided the power that brought fans out to the park.

Known as the "Babe Ruth of his era", Brouthers decorated career included five batting and two home run titles.  The premier 19th Century slugger led his league in slugging percentage six straight seasons (1882-87), and was one of just a handful of players during that era to belt over 100 career home runs.

Brouthers career began with the semipro Wappingers Falls Actives in 1878.  In 1879, he joined the Troy Trojans of the National League.  Struggling mightily in the field (34 errors in 39 games), he was shipped back to the minors.

The burley slugger surfaced with the NL's Buffalo Bisons in 1881 and was in the majors to stay.  During that season Brouthers topped the league in home runs with eight.  In 1882 and 1883 he won batting titles posting .368 and .374 averages, respectively.

Brouthers remained in Buffalo until 1886 when he was sold to the Detroit Wolverines.  He hit .370 and led the NL in home runs (11) and doubles (40).  In 1887 he led the Wolverines to their first pennant.  The team's success was short lived however, as the franchise folded following the 1888 season.  Brouthers was then awarded to the Boston Beaneaters.


After a batting title (.373) with the Beaneaters in 1889, Brouthers jumped to the Boston Reds of the newly formed Players' League.  The League was an offshoot of the Brotherhood of Professional Baseball Players, an association Brouthers helped form three years earlier.  The league lasted just one season, but the 6-2 205lb behemoth remained in Boston with the city's American Association Team.


With that version of the Boston Reds, Brouthers edged out teammate and future Hall of Famer Hugh Duffy for the batting title (.350).  In 1892 Brouthers headed back to the NL, joining the Brooklyn Grooms.  With the Grooms, he won his final big league batting title with a .335 mark.


In 1894, Brouthers headed south to Baltimore joining the NL's Orioles.  He remained in Baltimore for just over one season, helping them win their first pennant before being sold to Louisville Colonels.   After the 1895 season Brouthers was shipped to the Philadelphia Phillies.


Following that season in Philadelphia Brouthers bounced around the minors.  In 1903, he played in the only quadruple header of the 20th Century when his Poughkeepsie team of the Hudson River League lost four straight games.


In 1904, at age 46, the grizzled veteran won the Hudson River League batting championship with a .373 mark.  The strong season prompted a call up by the New York Giants, where Brouthers went hitless in a two game stint before retiring.


Following his career, Brouthers worked as a scout for the Giants and later was placed in charge of the Press Gate of the Polo Grounds.  He served in that capacity until his death in 1932.  In 1945, the Baseball Hall Fame finally acknowledged Brouthers and seven other neglected turn-of-the-century stars by enshrining them into its' hallowed halls.

-David Zingler, March 2003


Simply Baseball Notebook

DISCLAIMER: All pictures are assumed to be in the public domain. No violation of copyright is intended here. If one of the photos above is not in the public domain, please notify us and it will be removed.